//
VisionIAS - Video Classroom Lecture
Vision-IAS Logo


Security Class 01

REVISION OF THE PREVIOUS CLASS (01:15 PM)

CONTINUATION OF THE TOPIC OF SECURITY AGENCIES (01:20 PM)

INTELLIGENCE BUREAU 

Functions:

  • Counterintelligence:
  • IB is tasked with identifying and neutralizing threats posed by foreign intelligence agencies and espionage activities within India.
  • Counterterrorism:
  • IB plays a crucial role in identifying and thwarting terrorist threats within the country, working closely with law enforcement agencies to prevent terrorist attacks.
  • VIP Security:
  • IB is responsible for providing security assessments and protection to designated VIPs, including political leaders, government officials, and visiting dignitaries.
  • Anti-secession Activities:
  • IB monitors and counters activities aimed at promoting secessionist movements or undermining the integrity of the nation.
  • Intelligence Collection in Border Areas:
  • IB gathers intelligence from India's border regions to assess security threats and prevent infiltration by hostile elements.
  • Infrastructure Protection:
  • IB assesses and protects critical infrastructure assets vital to national security, such as transportation networks, energy facilities, and communication systems.
  • Overall, the Intelligence Bureau serves as a vital component of India's national security
    architecture, working tirelessly to safeguard the country's interests and protect its citizens from internal and external threats.

RESEARCH AND ANALYSIS WING (01:40 PM)

  • RAW, or the Research and Analysis Wing, stands as one of India's premier intelligence agencies, playing a critical role in safeguarding the nation's security interests.
  • Established in 1968, RAW was created primarily to focus on external intelligence gathering, especially concerning India's neighbouring countries, particularly Pakistan and China.
  • Before the formation of RAW, the Intelligence Bureau (IB) handled both internal and external intelligence matters.
  • However, recognizing the need for a dedicated agency to address the complexities of external threats, RAW was established under the leadership of then-Prime Minister Indira Gandhi.

Functions:

  • External Intelligence Gathering:
  • RAW's primary mandate revolves around gathering intelligence pertaining to India's external security threats, particularly from neighbouring countries like Pakistan and China.
  • It monitors political, military, and strategic developments in these nations, providing critical insights to policymakers.
  • Counterterrorism Operations:
  • RAW also plays a significant role in gathering intelligence related to terrorist activities and extremist organizations operating in the region.
  • Its efforts contribute to India's counterterrorism strategies and initiatives.
  • Foreign Policy Support:
  • RAW's intelligence assessments serve as a cornerstone for India's foreign policy formulation.
  • By monitoring political and military developments in neighbouring countries, RAW helps shape India's strategic engagements and responses to regional challenges.
  • Strategic Analysis:
  • RAW conducts an in-depth analysis of geopolitical trends, regional conflicts, and emerging threats to India's security interests.
  • Its assessments guide policymakers in making informed decisions on matters of national security and defence.
  • Covert Operations:
  • RAW is known for its ability to conduct covert operations to gather intelligence and disrupt hostile activities aimed at India's interests.
  • These operations are conducted with utmost secrecy and precision, often in collaboration with other intelligence agencies and special forces units.
  • Parliamentary Oversight:
  • Unlike other government agencies, RAW operates with a degree of autonomy and is not subject to direct parliamentary oversight on many issues.
  • This independence allows RAW to maintain secrecy and operational flexibility in carrying out its missions.

NATIONAL TECHNICAL RESEARCH ORGANISATION (01:49 PM)

  • The National Technical Research Organisation (NTRO) stands as a crucial component of India's intelligence apparatus, focusing on technical intelligence gathering and analysis.
  • Established in 2004 under the National Security Advisor in the Prime Minister's Office, NTRO plays a pivotal role in enhancing India's technological capabilities to address emerging security challenges.

Functions and responsibilities:

  • Aviation and remote sensing:
  • Uses advanced technologies to gather intelligence from aerial platforms.
  • Data gathering and processing:
  • Collects and analyzes data from various sources, including satellite imagery.
  • Cyber security:
  • Safeguards India's cyberspace from threats.
  • Cryptology systems:
  • Develops secure communications systems.
  • Strategic hardware and software development:
  • Designs and deploys strategic hardware and software solutions.
  • Strategic monitoring:
  • Conducts strategic monitoring of global events and emerging threats.
  • Satellite access and utilization:
  • Accesses data from satellites for intelligence gathering.

SHORTCOMINGS IN THE FUNCTIONING OF INTELLIGENCE AGENCIES (01:56 PM)

  • Internal rivalries and lack of cooperation among Indian intelligence agencies hamper collective efforts and compromise security.
  • Lack of coordination, information sharing, and joint operations result in gaps in intelligence gathering and analysis.
  • Limited oversight, accountability, and transparency mechanisms increase the risk of abuse of power and undermine public trust.
  • Secrecy and lack of disclosure erode public confidence and hinder accountability.
  • Political interference compromises the neutrality and objectivity of intelligence agencies, eroding public confidence.
  • Resource constraints, including funding, technology, and manpower shortages, limit the effectiveness and operational capabilities of intelligence agencies.

REFORMS NEEDED IN THE INTELLIGENCE AGENCIES (02:03 PM)

  • Intelligence agencies in India must be provided a legal-framework for their existence and functioning and their functioning must be under Parliamentary oversight and scrutiny.
  • Reforms in the recruitment and training processes of their personnel, their pay structures and career progression to attract the best talent available in the country.
  • Recruitment to these agencies should be broad-based so as experts from myriad fields, such as Science and Technology, IT, Communications etc could be brought, in rather than reserving these agencies exclusively for the Police Sector.
  • There should be a single authority exercising supervisory and other control over the intelligence agencies.
  • It could be the National Security Advisor (NSA) in a modified role, Director of National Intelligence or even a minister for national Intelligence, answerable to the Parliament.
  • Culture of Transparency should be promoted and inculcated as in the case of MI5
  • Greater empowerment of intelligence officials should be accompanied by a simultaneous strengthening of oversight.

CAPF (CENTRAL ARMED POLICE FORCES) (02:10 PM)

CHALLENGES FACED BY CAPF

Human resource related issue:

  • Extremely overburdened and understaffed.
  • The latest report suggests that more than 84000 posts are lying vacant in CAPF.
  • It results in the denial of leaves.
  • Psychological and mental stress.
  • High suicide rates (436 suicides in three years).
  • Till recently, pay was not at par with the armed forces.
  • Relatively poor promotional avenues as compared to IPS or the armed forces.
  • Paradropping of IPS officers as chiefs has a demotivating effect on the cadre.

Operational challenges:

  • States are over-dependent on CAPF.
  • CAPF is not able to get enough time for rest, recuperation, and training.
  • Lack of coordination between state police and CAPF.
  • Diversion of border guarding forces such as BSF towards other law and order duties.

Infrastructural challenges:

  • Shortage of arms.
  • The problem of poor quality food, medical facilities, and accommodation has a demotivating effect on CAPF.

REFORMS SUGGESTED (02:35 PM)

  • Training:
  • While purchasing state-of-the-art equipment, the government should ensure that training needs are taken care of and if needed, it may be included in the purchase agreement itself.
  • Further, it recommended that the training should be a mix of conventional matters and the latest technology like IT, cyber security, and cybercrime.
  • Modernisation:
  • Bottlenecks in procurement should be identified and corrective action taken.
  • Further, the Ministry of Home Affairs and CAPFs should hold negotiations with ordnance factories and manufacturers in the public or private sector to ensure an uninterrupted supply of equipment and other infrastructure.
  • Promotion of CAPF:
  • The Committee recommended that top positions should be filled from the respective cadre of the CAPF.
  • In addition, there was frustration in CAPFs due to stagnation in promotions and lack of cadre review.
  • The Committee recommended that a cadre review of all the CAPFs should be carried out within a defined timeline.

CBI (02:40 PM)

Functions:

  • Investigative Authority:
  • The CBI is empowered to investigate notified offences such as prevention of corruption independently.
  • For other offences like murder in any state, it requires the consent of the concerned states or orders from higher courts to investigate.
  • Scope of Investigations:
  • The CBI is renowned for investigating economic crimes, special crimes, cases of corruption, and other high-profile cases. It handles cases of national importance and significance.
  • Role in National Security:
  • The CBI's role extends beyond conventional crime investigation to matters of national security, including counterterrorism and intelligence gathering.
  • Collaboration and Coordination:
  • The CBI collaborates with other law enforcement agencies, both domestically and internationally, to address transnational crimes and enhance investigative capabilities.

Problems associated with CBI:

  • Loss of Public Confidence:
  • The Supreme Court's scathing characterization of the CBI as a 'caged parrot' significantly tarnished its reputation and integrity.
  • Political pressure and interference have further eroded public trust in the organization.
  • Delays and Inefficiencies:
  • The CBI has been criticized for extensive delays in concluding investigations, leading to perceptions of ineffectiveness.
  • Former Central Vigilance Commissioner likened the CBI to a 'black hole' where cases seemingly disappear without resolution.
  • Reports of Misconduct:
  • Numerous reports have surfaced alleging dishonesty and harassment of the public by CBI personnel, casting doubts on the agency's ethical
    standards and professionalism.
  • Dependence on State Governments:
  • Despite being a central agency, the CBI relies on state governments to invoke its authority to investigate cases within their jurisdiction.
  • This dependency poses significant challenges, particularly when investigating cases involving central government employees.
  • Lack of Autonomy and Cadre:
  • The CBI lacks functional autonomy, relying on the home ministry for staffing and the law ministry for legal support. Its dependence on IPS officers, who are susceptible to government influence, further undermines its autonomy and impartiality.
  • Vulnerability to Government Influence:
  • The CBI's structure, run by IPS officers on deputation, makes it susceptible to manipulation by the government, which holds control over senior officer postings and career advancement.
  • Jurisdictional Constraints:
  • While the CBI operates under the provisions of the Code of Criminal Procedure (CrPC), its jurisdiction is subject to the consent of state governments, hindering its ability to operate effectively across the country.

Way forward:

  • CBI needs an autonomous legal framework and quality supervision.
  • Political interference in CBI appointments must end.
  • CBI should have its own cadre of officers, free from transfers.
  • Granting autonomy to CBI and other agencies with parliamentary oversight can ensure accountability.
  • Improve service conditions and emoluments for direct recruits to attract skilled people.

ROLE OF EXTERNAL STATE ACTORS IN CREATING CHALLENGES TO INDIA'S INTERNAL SECURITY (02:53 PM)

BANGLADESH

  • a) Illegal immigration.
  • b) Ongoing radicalization/fundamentalism will have spillover effects in India even promoting communal tensions.
  • c) Refugee crisis (Rohingyas) which may create conflicts in Indian society, pressure on our resources, and security threats.
  • d) Safe refuge for insurgents, for example, ULFA.
  • e) Illegal cattle smuggling of over 1 lakh cattle from India have been illegally smuggled to Bangladesh.
  • This may create conflicts and polarisation in the Indian Society.
  • f) Human Trafficking on the Bangladesh border.
  • This is sponsoring various other criminal activities and insurgency.
  • g) Increasing proximity of Bangladesh and China.

NEPAL (03:26 PM)

  • Cross-border criminal activities:
  • Drug trafficking, human trafficking, gold trafficking.
  • Safe passage for various organised crimes.
  • The influx of FICNs compromising our economic sovereignty.
  • Various extremist groups receiving training and support from Nepal:
  • As per, the 2008 MHA Report 40 Maoist received training in Nepal.
  • Political instability in Nepal has repercussions in India for example radicalisation of youth in border districts.
  • Growing proximity between Nepal and China.

MYANMAR (03:35 PM)

  • Cross-border movement of insurgent groups such as the Nationalist Socialist Council of Nagaland and ULFA across the Indo-Myanmar border has supported the thriving of the insurgency in India's North-East.
  • Drug Trafficking:
  • Myanmar is a part of the infamous Golden Triangle and Smuggling of Narcotics into India poses a significant security threat.
  • The Rohingya Refugee crisis has a spillover effect onto India's northeast creating multi-dimensional challenges for India's internal security.
  • Political instability in Myanmar has weakened the rule of law in the country and has allowed the thriving of insurgent groups and Organised Criminal Groups (OCGs) in the region.
  • Activities of transnational OCGs operating near the Indo-Myanmar border pose challenges to India's border management forces.

AFGHANISTAN (03:46 PM)

  • It is a major producer of opium and has fueled drug trafficking and addiction in India posing several social and security challenges to India.
  • Afghanistan's geopolitical instability and power struggle within the various factions have created insecurity and security dilemmas for India.
  • Pakistan continues to use Afghanistan's territory for training militants and terrorists as well as for strategic depth.

PAKISTAN (03:53 PM)

  • Pakistan's support for terror groups such as Lashkar -e- Taiba, and Hizbul Mujahiddin pose a significant security threat to India.
  • Involvement in drug trafficking via Indo - Pakistan border in Punjab, Rajasthan, and Gujarat.
  • The influx of Fake Indian Currency Notes (FICN) via Pakistan is a threat to India's Sovereignty.
  • Pakistan's impression of minority rights and support for fundamentalist ideology has contributed to radicalisation within Indian society.
  • All weather friendship between Pakistan and China and the increasing presence of the Chinese military is a cause of strategic and security concern for India.

CHINA (04:00 PM)

  • Border incursions by PLA with respect to territorial disputes.
  • Assertive and aggressive Chinese expansionist policy in Ladakh, Arunachal, South China Sea is a matter of concern.
  • Strategic Encirclement of India by establishing deeper diplomatic ties

THE TOPIC TO BE DISCUSSED IN THE NEXT CLASS- Terrorism